Caruso's Italian Fine Foods Menu (Updated October 2025)

Welcome to Caruso's Italian Fine Foods, where authentic Italian flavors come alive! Nestled at 64 New York Ave, Halesite, NY, this charming eatery is a feast for the senses and a culinary gem cherished by locals and visitors alike.

The extensive menu features an array of hearty soups like the comforting Lentil and savory Onion Soup, each priced at just $5.00. For a quick and flavorful option, don’t miss the wraps, such as the Soprano Wrap filled with hot capicolla and sharp provolone for $8.00, or the classic Chicken Honey Mustard Wrap.

The stars of the menu are undoubtedly the heroes. Indulge in the Italian Hero—a mouthwatering combination of prosciutto, salami, and fresh mozzarella for $10.00. Diners rave about the Tutto Pazza Hero as well, a delightful mix of imported prosciutto and provolone for just $9.00.

But what truly sets Caruso's apart is its commitment to freshness and quality, from the homemade fried eggplant to their renowned sandwiches. Customers frequently praise the warm atmosphere, reminiscent of Little Italy, as the family-run establishment creates a welcoming and friendly vibe. With daily specials that include marinated skirt steak and chicken cacciatore, Caruso's exemplifies the heart of Italian cuisine, promising an unforgettable experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.